Whyle attended La Salle High School in Cincinnati, Ohio, where he played football and excelled as a tight end. He was highly recruited out of high school and ultimately committed to play college football at the University of Cincinnati. During his time at Cincinnati, Whyle proved to be a versatile player, showcasing his skills as both a receiver and a blocker. He became a key player for the Bearcats’ offense and helped lead the team to multiple successful seasons.