Jutkiewicz started his professional career at Swindon Town before moving to Premier League side Everton in 2007. He spent several loan spells at various clubs before joining Coventry City in 2012, where he enjoyed a successful spell and earned a move to Middlesbrough in 2014. Jutkiewicz later joined Burnley in 2014 and eventually signed for Birmingham City in 2016, where he has become a key player for the club.